The nine audit criteria. Every mystery enquiry is scored 0–100 on nine criteria. A channel’s score is the weighted average, less 8 points per red flag (capped at 24). A channel that never replied inside the 7-day window scores 0.
| Criterion | Weight | What it measures |
|---|
| Response time | 20 | How quickly the enquiry received its first substantive reply. |
| Answered at all | 10 | Whether the enquiry was acknowledged and engaged with on the channel it arrived on. |
| Accuracy vs fact sheet | 15 | Prices, services and availability quoted, checked against what the business publishes. |
| Personalisation | 10 | Use of the prospect's name and reference to their stated need. |
| Qualification questions | 10 | Whether the team asked questions to understand the prospect's situation and fit. |
| Follow-up cadence | 10 | Persistence and spacing of follow-ups over the 7-day observation window. |
| Close attempt / next step | 10 | Whether a concrete next step (booking, call, visit) was proposed. |
| Tone & professionalism | 5 | Courtesy, clarity and brand-appropriate language throughout. |
| Red flags | 10 | Absence of red flags: unauthorised third-party contact (data-leak signal), pressure to go off-channel, discount freelancing, PII mishandling. 100 = clean. |
Every enquiry channel the business offers. The enquiry form, email, live chat and WhatsApp on the business’s website, and a phone call where the business’s plan includes one. A channel the business does not offer (no chat on the site, for example) is recorded as not offered and is never held against it. A channel it does offer cannot be left out to improve the result.
Certification per site on SalesWitness Multi. A business with several websites, service lines or locations is certified per site: each site is assessed on its own channels against these rules and receives its own certificate, number and verification page.
Review response. How the business responds to its public reviews is monitored and reported alongside the audit. It is reported, not a pass/fail condition: it never earns or loses a certificate.